School superintendent on educational reform

JULIE LANE FILE PHOTO | Shelter Island School Superintendent Michael Hynes.

As I was re-reading some of my books about educational leadership over the past few weeks, I stumbled upon one of my favorite authors, Michael Fullan. Mr. Fullan has written several books about education over the past 25 years.

The following excerpt was taken from one of his best, “The New Meaning of Educational Change” (2001, 3rd Edition).

The reason I am sharing this piece with you is due to the timeliness of what is happening within our school and what he wrote in his best-selling book.

Below you will find the essence of “Chapter 1: A Brief History of Educational Change.” Some parts were left out due to the fact it is a relatively long chapter, but amazing nonetheless. I hope you enjoy it and will welcome any comments you may have to share.

One person claims that schools are being bombarded by change; another observes that there is nothing new under the sun. A policy-maker charges that teachers are resistant to change; a teacher complains that administrators introduce change for their own self-aggrandizement and that they neither know what is needed nor understand the classroom. A parent is bewildered by the new practice in reading and by the relevance of education in future jobs. Some argue that restructuring schools is the only answer, while others decry that this too is just a pipe dream diverting our attention from the core curriculum changes that are desperately needed. One university professor is convinced that schools are only a reflection of society and cannot be expected to bring change; another professor is equally convinced that schools would be all right if only superintendents and principals had more “vision” as educational leaders, and teachers were more motivated to learn new approaches to improving curriculum. A governor works hard to get major new legislation passed to reform education, a principal thinks, “this too shall pass.” Charter schools are hailed simultaneously as saving the day and destroying the public education system. Commercial entities take over school districts and claim that they can do a better job. States pass dramatic legislation to serve notice to “failing schools” and “failing school districts” with corresponding invasive interventions intended to make things right. Standards-based reform is held up as the answer to our woes.

Amidst all the turmoil, agents at all levels wonder how to get more and more programs institutionalized, while teachers think it is these same promoters of change who should be institutionalized, not the programs. Students are too distracted by a host of other matters to pay much attention to all the uproar. Today it is abundantly clear that one of the keys to successful change is improvement of relationships (Fullan, 2001) — precisely the focus of group development.

We have learned over the past decade that the process of educational reform is much more complex than we anticipated. Even the apparent successes have fundamental flaws. For example, in our development work we have been interested in how long it takes to turn around a poor performing school or district to become a good or better performing system. Our current conclusion is that you can turn around an elementary school in about three years, a high school in about six years, and a school district (depending on the size) in about eight years (Fullan, 1999, 2000b).

As valid as these general conclusions are, there are three problems. First, the time lines are too long. Given the sense of urgency, people rightly ask: Can these time lines be accelerated? Say reduced by half? The answer is yes, which we will see does not solve the problem.

Second, the number of examples of turnaround is small. There is only a minority of elementary schools, and fewer high schools and school districts, that are engaged in this manner. In other words, we have not nearly gone to scale where the majority of schools improve. It is not enough to have a handful of successful cases. 

Third, and most revealing, it takes three, six, eight years of hard work to produce improvement, but the results are fragile. One or two key people leave and the success can be undone almost overnight. Thus, from the point of view of “sustaining change,” even in those small numbers of cases, there are serious problems.

The main reason change fails to occur in the first place on any scale, and does not get sustained when it does, is that the infrastructure is weak, unhelpful, or working at cross purposes. By infrastructure I mean the next layers above whatever unit we are focusing on. In terms of successive levels, for example, a teacher cannot sustain change if he or she is working in a negative school culture; similarly, a school can initiate and implement successful change, but cannot sustain it if operating in a less than helpful district; a district cannot keep going if it works in a state which is not helping to sustain reform. 

In other words we have our work cut out. This is not a race to see who can become the most innovative. The key words are meaning, coherence, connectedness, synergy, alignment, and capacity for continuous improvement. Paradoxically, if meaning is easy to come by it is less likely to be powerful. Simple systems are more meaningful but less deep. Complex systems generate overload and confusion, but also contain more power and energy. Our task is to realize that finding meaning in complex systems is a difficult as it is rewarding. 

In closing, I believe Mr. Fullan clearly articulates what is presently taking place at our school. I believe we now have meaning, coherence, connectedness, synergy, alignment and the capacity for continuous improvement. As I have said before, our school won’t get to Point B overnight, but we will get there and our children will be all the better for it.

References:

Fullan, M. (1999) “Change Forces. The Sequel,” Philadelphia: Falmer Press/Taylor & Francis Inc.

Fullan, M. (June 23, 2000), “Infrastructure Is All,” London Times Education Supplement, 19, p.15

Fullan, M. (2001) “Leading in a Culture of Change,” San Francisco: Jossey-Bass

15 Comment

  • H Block, a leading taxpreparation company, flipped between the slogans “America’s tax team,” “Just plain smart,” and its current “Get it Right” in just a few years. The fragmentation risks leaving consumers unable to discern a single brand identity for the company. Lastly, in order to fasten the link between a tagline and brand identity, many taglines incorporate the brand name. Citibank’s “Because the Citi never sleeps” and Finish Detergent’s “Brilliant cleaning starts with Finish” are examples. However, some brands may purposefully choose to leave out their names so that their taglines or slogans don’t impair future brand extensions.and the bored wife who dished up a global hit Food for thought: Julie and Julia is based on the life of Julie Powell who cooked her way through every recipe of Mastering The Art Of French Cooking to take her mind off her boring life When Julie Powell decided to cook her way through the 524 recipes of Julia Child’s iconic book, Mastering The Art Of French Cooking, in a single year, she was just looking for a domestic project to take her mind off her deadend secretarial job.

  • Best replica watches with genuine Swiss movement for sale

  • and Marketing Duties at Two Centers INDIANAPOLIS, June 24 /PRNewswireFirstCall/ Simon Property Group, Inc. (NYSE: SPG), the country’s largest owner, developer and manager of high quality retail real estate, announced today that it will assume leasing, management, and marketing duties of two highquality shopping centers, Galleria Dallas and Novi Town Center in Novi, Michigan. Simon will commence these roles at the two properties on August 1. “We are pleased to take on the property management functions of these highquality assets at the request of the institutional owner,” said Rick Sokolov, Simon’s President and Chief Operating Officer. Galleria Dallas has been a Metroplex landmark since its debut in 1982. Two hundred stores and over 1,300,000 square feet of total gross leasable area entice residents and visitors alike. Galleria Dallas is anc
    toms outlet http://www.grbcga.com/

  • Living up to its heritage, Crysis 3 brings the APU to its knees Image Credit: Crytek

  • Ideas for Thanksgiving Dinner Hostess Gifts

  • E redattore capo del quotidiano La Stampa e qui nel 1981 fonda e dirige di una trentina di libri, prevalentemente di divulgazione scientifica, molti dei quali tradotti in francese e in spagnolo, la International Astronomical Union ha intitolato con il suo nome il pianetino 4821 che orbita tra Marte e Giove e questo in omaggio alla sua quarantennale attivit nella divulgazione scientifica.

  • He dropped the plan when it became obvious that the Obama administration had no intention of pushing Karzai from power. Working the phones late at night from his home in the San Diego suburbs, Clarridge maintained a network of spies who were gathering information on Taliban groups such as the Haqqani network. Through a Pentagon contract overseen by Lockheed Martin, Clarridge and his team were paid $22 million for their work and filed of intelligence reports to military commanders in Afghanistan. The CIA had always been unhappy about Clarridge freelance spying operation, and his contract was not renewed in 2010. He was angry that his former employer to be the reason that the operation had been shut down. Mazzetti, a national security correspondent for the New York Times, asserts that the on terror has damaged the CIA ability to understand the really important political developments in the Muslim world, such as the Arab Spring. As a senior Obama official explained, noting the agency emphasis on drone strikes and hunting down alQaeda leaders: CIA missed Tunisia.
    cheap toms http://www.apmc04.org.in/

  • business will continue via a sublicense with Outlook Eyewear.

  • France FRAAfghanistan AFGAlbanie ALBAlgérie DZASamoa américaines ASMAndorre ANDAngola AGOAnguilla AIAAntigua et Barbuda ATGArgentine ARGArménie ARMAruba ABWAustralie AUSAutriche AUTRépublique azerbaïdjanaise AZEBahamas BHSBahreïn BHRBangladesh BGDBarbade BRBBiélorussie BLRBelgique BELBelize BLZBénin BENBermudes BMUBhoutan BTNBolivie BOLBosnie Herzégovine BIHBotswana BWABrésil BRAIles Vierges britanniques VGBBrunéi Darussalam BRNBulgarie BGRBurkina Faso BFABirmanie MMRBurundi BDICambodge KHMCameroun CMRCanada CANIles du Cap Vert CPVIles Caïmans CYMRépublique centrafricaine CAFTchad TCDChili CHLChine CHNColombie COLComores COMCongo, République démocratique du CODRépublique du Congo COGIles Cook COKCosta Rica CRICôte d’Ivoire CIVCroatie, République de HRVChypre CYPRépublique tchèque CZEDanemark DNKDjibouti DJIDominique DMADominicaine, République DOMEquateur ECUEgypte EGYSalvador SLVGuinée équatoriale GNQErythrée ERIEstonie ESTEthiopie ETHIles Falkland (Iles Malouines) FLKFidjien FJIFinlande FINFrance FRAGuyane française GUFPolynésie française PYFRépublique du Gabon GABGambie GMBGeorgia GEOAllemagne DEUGhana GHAGibraltar GIBGrèce GRCGroenland GRLGrenade GRDGuadeloupe GLPGuam GUMGuatemala GTMGuernesey GGYGuinée GINGuinée Bissau GNBGuyane GUYHaïti HTIHonduras HNDHong Kong HKGHongrie HUNIslande ISLInde INDIndonésie IDNIrlande IRLIsraël ISRItalie ITAJamaïque JAMJapon JPNJersey JEYJordanie JORKazakhstan KAZKenya KENKiribati KIRCorée du Sud KORKoweït KWTKirghizstan KGZLaos LAOLettonie LVALiban LBNLiechtenstein LIELituanie LTULuxembourg LUXMacao MACMacédoine MKDMadagascar MDGMalawi MWIMalaisie MYSMaldives MDVMali MLIMalte MLTIles Marshall MHLMartinique MTQMauritanie MRTMaurice MUSMayotte MYTMexique MEXMicronésie FSMMoldavie MDAMonaco MCOMongolie MNGMonténégro MNEMontserrat MSRMaroc MARMozambique MOZNamibie NAMNauru NRUNépal NPLPays Bas NLDAntilles néerlandaises ANTNouvelle Calédonie NCLNouvelle Zélande NZLNicaragua NICNiger NERNigéria NGANiué NIUNorvège NOROman OMNPakistan PAKPalau PLWPanama PANPapouasie Nouvelle Guinée PNGParaguay PRYPérou PERPhilippines PHLPologne POLPortugal PRTPorto Rico PRIQatar QATRéunion REURoumanie ROURussie, Fédération de RUSRwanda RWASainte Hélène SHNSaint Kitts et Nevis KNASainte Lucie LCASaint Pierre et Miquelon SPMSaint Vincent et les Grenadines VCTSaint Marin SMRArabie saoudite SAUSénégal SENSerbie SRBSeychelles SYCSierra Leone SLESingapour SGPSlovaquie SVKSlovénie SVNIles Salomon SLBSomalie SOMAfrique du Sud ZAFEspagne ESPSri Lanka LKASurinam SURSwaziland SWZSuède SWESuisse CHETaiwan TWNTadjikistan TJKTanzanie TZAThaïlande THATogo TGOTonga TONTrinité et Tobago TTOTunisie TUNTurquie TURTurkménistan TKMIles Turks et Caicos TCATuvalu TUVOuganda UGAUkraine UKREmirats Arabes Unis ARERoyaume Uni UKEtats Unis USAUruguay URUOuzbékistan UZBVanuatu VUTEtat de la Cité du Vatican VATVenezuela VENVietnam VNMIles Vierges américaines VIRWallis et Futuna WLFSahara occidental ESHSamoa occidentales WSMYémen YEMZambie ZMBZimbabwe ZWE.Mouvement évangélique dans le monde

  • Ha inoltre interpretato il ruolo di Bethany Horowitz nella serie prodotta dall American Broadcasting Company Boston Legal.

  • Joe recently appeared on “The Dr. Oz Show” to discuss his juicing secrets and provide a three day weight loss cleanse: Get the details by clicking here.Justice Foundation’s President Arrested

  • Men Business Also Holds Upside

  • Irrrm a sucker for those eso gold. We’ve scratched and chipped these businesses Typical since i have received these.

  • Later, he moved to Normal and worked as a project engineer at the Eureka Co. until his retirement.

  • Some of these eso gold are usually an excellent fashion accessory. Definitely invaluable!