From the ashes: Remembering the Presbyterian Church inferno

REPORTER FILE PHOTO |  Shelter Island Presbyterian Church was rebuilt in the 1930s after the original 1861 structure was destroyed by fire 80 winters ago this week.

Shelter Island Presbyterian Church was rebuilt in the 1930s after the original 1861 structure was destroyed by fire 80 winters ago this month.

It initially appeared to be a mystery — how an iconic Shelter Island building, holding many chapters of its history  could suddenly be engulfed in flames burning so hot and so fast that nothing was left but rubble.

The mystery surrounding the tragedy that befell the church, built in 1861, was solved quickly: It was the work of a young arsonist.

An unnamed 17-year-old confessed to  officers of the Shelter Island Police Department he was responsible for the blaze that consumed Shelter Island Presbyterian Church on the night of February 6, 1934. But another mystery remains buried with the scorched debris of the church: There are no details of subsequent court action, or the motive, or fate of the young man.

Because he was only 17, his name wasn’t released by authorities at the time. Phyllis Wallace, who maintains the Shelter Island Historical Society’s records, said there were rumors at the time but she could find no information about how his case was handled by the courts. Several accounts of the fire never revealed the youth’s name or more information on his arrest.

But here is no mystery about what happened to the Presbyterian church. The fire was so intense that a witness saw the church’s “large bell … dashed to the ground and shattered into pieces.”

In days following, the sadness of the community was seen on many faces since, then as now, the church was as much community center as place of worship.

“The flames burned with such rapidity that nothing remained of the edifice and its adjoining chapel but blackened embers when dawn arrived,” according to a newspaper account at the time.

If the nighttime fire shocked the Island, the following day found a community subdued in mourning.

“When our Presbyterian Church disappeared in a blaze of light on that fatal night, the flames carried with them more than material matter,” according to a pamphlet that was written by Ralph Duvall, a church member at the time.

“The old building represented the prayers and prose and loving labor of the people of this church for nearly six score years,” Mr. Duvall wrote. “The great tragedy is in the history of Shelter Island and its loss is keenly felt by the people of this community.”

His words were also captured in a paper he wrote and gave to the Shelter Island Historical Society to provide a record of the event. He recalled Shelter Island being “enshrouded in a the gloomy darkness of a cold mid-winter night” with the temperature at 10 below zero, when people were “startled by the dreaded wail of the fire siren.”

Many people thought someone’s house was on fire, but when the sirens continued, they were alerted to the reality of a large blaze somewhere in the Center. Residents began to gather around 8:30 p.m. to watch as firefighters could do little more than watch the building burn.

Because heavy ice had frozen the bays, resulting in ferries being out of service for a week, there was no mutual aid coming from firefighters on the North and South forks.

The fire burned itself out in less than three hours.

Betty Kontje, who was five-years-old, watched the leaping flames from her front porch on Smith Street.

Her mother had gone to the store that was across from the school so her father, who was a firefighter, was unable to go to the scene until her mother returned. When he did go to the church, he saw the difficulty his fellow firefighters were having trying to contain the inferno without help from surrounding departments, she remembered.

By morning’s light, all that was left of the church and adjoining chapel was “a mass of metal and a heap of burning embers,” Mr. Duvall wrote. All that could be saved was a large Bible, a very few pieces of furniture and a few church records that had been “snatched form the fiery flames,” he said.

“I was devastated the next day when I went by the church,” Ms. Kontje said. “It was a horror to see it.”

She had gone to Sunday school there every week as a child, where her mother was one of the teachers. It was a home away from home, she said.

Tom Young remembers crying when he passed the site on his way to school that morning. “I cried because I loved that church,” said Mr. Young, a long-time Island resident who now makes his home in Florida. Six-years-old at the time, he wasn’t present the night the church burned, but told a reporter on the 50th anniversary of the fire in 1984, that the church was “the central part of our lives.”

The Reverend Donald Shaw, who was pastor at the time of the 50th anniversary of the fire, said “rebuilding became a community project with many individuals lending their time, equipment and know-how.”

A history of the events on the church website calls the rebuilding the result of a “determined and intrepid spirit,” recounting that the congregation “erected the present sanctuary and fellowship hall in little more than a year.”

29 Comment

  • [url=【カパース】ロングパンツ〈フットサル?サッカー?ナイロンパンツ〉Ca110202-jp-2227.html]ナイロンパンツ[/url]
    [url=【キャルデラ】Piste-pants-”Wander”ピステパンツ ワンダー〈サッカ-jp-2505.html]ピステパンツ[/url]

    [url=<Rilakkuma/リラックマ>玄関マット スカイハッピー(リラックマ)-jp-2186.html]玄関マット[/url]
    [url=くつホルダー シューズストッカー QB Eワイド6個組み ( 靴 収納 靴ホルダー 靴箱 下駄箱 く-jp-2225.html]シューズストッカ[/url]
    [url=コートハンガー 立てかけハンガーラックFB ( パイプハンガー 木製 オープンラック ディスプレイラ-jp-2459.html]立てかけハンガー[/url]
    [url=【scroll コラボ商品】<Rubanchouリュバンシュ>ビジュートイレマットAH -jp-3229.html]ビジュートイレマット[/url]
    [url=<となりのトトロ>となりのトトロ ウールひざ掛けE【送料無料】-jp-2053.html]ウールひざ掛け[/url]
    [url=<くまのがっこう>トイレマット(クールチャッキー) E(ロールカバー)-jp-2817.html]ロールカバー[/url]
    [url=ガーゼケット 5重 TA ドット シングル用 ( 掛け布団 毛布 寝具 タオルケット )-jp-2096.html]タオルケット[/url]
    [url=アイアンハンガーラックPB45 B(収納棚付き)※メーカーお届け品-jp-2524.html]アイアンハンガーラック[/url]

    [url=新品-disney-mobile-dm012sh-style-pink-jp-2245.html]disney mobile[/url]
    [url=新品-p06c-レッド-携帯電話-ガラケー-白ロム-ドコモ-docomo-jp-2214.html]ドコモ docomo[/url]
    [url=新品-aquos-phone-zeta-sh06e-blue-携帯電話-スマートフォン-白ロム-ドコ-jp-2158.html]スマートフォン ドコモ[/url]
    [url=新品-apple-ipad-retinaディスプレイモデル-wifi-16gb-ホワイト-(第4世代-jp-2025.html]apple ipad[/url]
    [url=新品-apple-ipad2-wifiモデル-64gb-ホワイト-第2世代-fc981ja-未使用品-jp-2029.html]apple ipad2 第3世代[/url]
    [url=新品-galaxy-note-ii-sc02e-marble-white-携帯電話-スマートフォン--jp-2186.html]galaxy note ii[/url]
    [url=新品-galaxy-note-ii-sc02e-amber-brown-携帯電話-スマートフォン-ド-jp-2185.html]galaxy note ii[/url]
    [url=新品-apple-ipad2-wifiモデル-16gb-ブラック-第2世代-fc769ja-未使用品-jp-2026.html]apple ipad2 第2世代[/url]
    [url=新品-xperia-tablet-z-so03e-white-タブレット端末-ドコモ-docomo-jp-2235.html]xperia tablet[/url]

    [url=レディース-ゴルフウェアプリーツスカート☆ゴルフウェアもおしゃれに着こなしたい-jp-2099.html]venus shot レディース[/url]
    [url=スノーボードウェアメンズユニセックス-ジャケット&パンツ上下セット☆Stylef-jp-2166.html]43degrees スノーボードウェア[/url]
    [url=取り外しライナー付き プレミアムコットンのトレンチコート※ ページ上は98cm丈でございます-jp-2161.html]プレミアムコットン[/url]

    [url=【予約】Steiffシュタイフ 世界限定ペーパーテディベア-jp-8201.html]ペーパーテディベア[/url]
    [url=【ミニチュア】クラシックテディベア モヘア12cm■黄色タグ(定番)■シュタイフ-jp-7888.html]クラシックテディベア[/url]
    [url=【コージーフレンズ】チャーリー テディベア 23cm ■シュタイフ ぬいぐるみ テディーベアー テデ-jp-7793.html]テディーベアー[/url]
    [url=【ミニチュア】シュタイフ世界限定アンカー フェルトテディベア シーサイド ぬいぐるみ テディーベアー-jp-7876.html]フェルトテディベア[/url]
    [url=★10off特価&送料無料★プリンス ビーバーハート ぬいぐるみ テディーベアー テディーベア テデ-jp-8587.html]ビーバーハート[/url]
    [url=【オーダーメイド】モヘアテディベア バース ブロンド■シュタイフテディベアぬいぐるみ-jp-8221.html]バース[/url]
    [url=【ミニチュア】2007年 アルパカ パンダ テッド■シュタイフ社テディベア-jp-7902.html]パンダ[/url]
    [url=★35off★モーツァルト ウイズ ミュージカル オーナメント■世界限定シュタイフ社テディベア ぬい-jp-7905.html]オーナメント[/url]

    [url=【送料無料】Koden広電 3畳用 ホットカーペット(電気カーペット 本体:ダニ退治 カバー:フリー-jp-7737.html]ホットカーペット[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】コロナcorona 対流型石油ストーブ対流式石油ストーブ 2317畳用 タンク一体式 遠-jp-7651.html]対流型ストーブ[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】Hxc120w 加湿セラミックファンヒータープラズマクラスター7000、空中除菌、花粉対-jp-7642.html]加湿ヒーター[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】【Hvc50w】シャープsharp ハイブリッド加湿器 プラズマクラスター搭載空気浄化・-jp-7672.html]加湿器[/url]
    [url=【代引不可】【送料無料】ダイキン ルームエアコン 単相200v rxシリーズ 主に26畳用 うるさら-jp-7487.html]ルームエアコン[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】【Bbh37】阪和hanwa アロマ加湿器 レクトロ touchタッチ おしゃれなデザイ-jp-7729.html]レクトロ[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】【Kap50xw】東芝 気化式加湿器 ウルオスulos 木造85畳・洋室14畳程度 おし-jp-7730.html]東芝[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】シャープsharp-プラズマクラスター除湿機 「衣類乾燥」除湿器部屋干し除菌脱臭花粉【0-jp-7607.html]除湿機[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】コイズミ ダイニングコタツ和モダン、カジュアルタイプ、電気こたつ 天然木突板 90×75-jp-7677.html]コイズミ[/url]
    [url=【送料無料】ごろ寝マットホットカーペット・ホットマット・電気マット・敷きパッド・ソファーカバー 約1-jp-7772.html]コロナ[/url]

  • One important issue is that if you find yourself searching for a student loan you may find that you’ll need a co-signer. There are many circumstances where this is true because you will find that you do not possess a past credit history so the bank will require that you’ve got someone cosign the credit for you. Thanks for your post.

  • Great beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your site, how could i subscribe for a blog site? The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  • You could certainly see your expertise in the work you write. The world hopes for even more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. Always follow your heart.

  • Listing of constructive steps to discover more on watch well before you are left out.

  • Tired of the men gossip? I’m on this site for you!!

  • Related article: Jordan’s unsung sightsBut away from the deep yawn of the gully that marks the main tourist route, an entire network of winding Bedouin back roads, narrow goat trails and worn rock cut staircases wind across the russet hued cliffs, gloriously empty of visitors; their stony paths leading to rarely visited monuments and panoramic vistas. Even in one of the world’s most popular sights it is still possible to escape the crowds.

  • A perfect key for the men that it’s possible to understand more about straight away.

  • End Protesting , Start Off your own men Call campaign Instead

  • Looking for quality cheap shoes? ShoeOcean is an independent online retailer committed to provide great deals on women flat sandals, fashion boots, bridal shoes,
    cheap christian louboutin uk

  • I use the elder scrolls online gold to check out get the job done and to go out at night. Have some complian.

  • I am really loving the theme/design of your weblog. Do you ever run into any browser compatibility issues? A handful of my blog readers have complained about my website not working correctly in Explorer but looks great in Safari. Do you have any advice to help fix this problem?

  • Romantically speaking, Allen is additional of a heartthrob form. He may have a a lot larger, magic formula supporter foundation among the gumsnapping girls who established off tsunamis of text and phone votes that make a decision winners each and every 7 days. Moreover, Lambert likes to leap off cliffs, creatively speaking. What if he goes splat in the course of the final faceoff?

  • I grandi shopping center offrono soprattutto articoli internazionali (cosmetici, biancheria, giocattoli) a prezzi molto vantaggiosi.

  • Innovative new watch Guide Reveal Simple Tips To Rule The watch Marketplace

  • Most Important Method That Is Actually Helping bag-experts Growing

  • From the ashes: Remembering the Presbyterian Church inferno | Shelter Island Reporter

  • Hi, I have merely requested some sort of immigration program code form america online broadband internet to ensure that i can join sky potential, on reading all these information i believe i might made a mistake. I possess not yet obtained my very own apple pc codes and so do not trained with to help atmosphere, am i allowed to continue with america online because typical or will certainly they will ending this connection? NO COST appears very good but is not immediately after reading this web page. Many cheers wendy

  • Ai stiut ungef?r sony ericsson poate spiona premature ejaculation rapid ejaculation, rapid climax, premature climax, bing messenger dupa cei attention ze pun invizibili? Nu se no pot ascunde dupa acel aol reputation, numit hidden, deoarece exista united nations yahoo-spy attention ii detecteaza! Asta areal fi yahoo-spy. com. Distractie placuta!

  • While I would certainly commonly recognize, in this instance it can somewhat little. In addition, Wikipedia offers arrive a lengthy approaches since it seemed to be bashed regarding permitting people to modify written content, there are lots of squads involving moderators that trail as well as repair the many flaws standard users help make any time adding/editing the wiki article.

  • Fine content, great to view folks a little societal accountability.

  • WOW just what I was searching for. Came here by searching for turnicidae

  • You happen to be rightIbrahim: Search having Search engines this new driver: winxp_Graphic remote line 945GMLit works good together with your LG ELECTRONICS R400 laptop Make sure you assist me to while my very own Wireless is not operating. In the past it is has been functioning today soon after brand new installation of Windowpane EXPERIENCE it has the not working. Although I have tested out often to run Bluetooth’s drivers. If anyone can certainly correct this concern, you should assist me to. We will probably be fortunate in order to regarding this. Regards, Younis

  • I like eso gold. apple large several frames and become these items just about every single frosty. all of them are critical. these are the fashionest along with sweetest eso gold. A only a few twos have could be the black colored coquette eso gold slipper, quick regular chestnut in addition to orange sand baily tab and so forth .. The very coquette is ok, this works absent from additionally the beyond dog’s hair is getting stiff. On the other hand goes with most things and is particularly goood for only a easy slip on. The actual proverb have become the most straightforward and best of them all of. it is the one particular everybody’s got low grouses, that will pursue to have that a number of partners with the rest of playing. In addition to, the entire bailey link happen to be extremly cute plus i romance all the orange sand shade. I understand the perimeters work to times throughout over time of time and energy nevertheless i realistically opt to doing it not ever. it’s going too low.

  • My partner and i stumbled across the identical matter if at first I had been attempting to work out exactly why stuff have been consuming such a long time in order to acquire with this provider. I put the actual social networking tabs displaying inside Home windows Task Manager in addition to remarked that when I give up from the program, the networking network was still getting used. With testing further I ran across that even if My spouse and i shut down the actual PC and also rebooted the system network should still be used with this program.

  • Hi there, everything is going perfectly here and ofcourse every one
    is sharing data, that’s really good, keep up writing.

  • The particular reason why no-one is speaking about watch and therefore what one ought to engage in right away.

  • This post is invaluable. When can I find out more?