Last week the veil was lifted on a question at the center of the East End’s culture as well as its economy: How many Peconic Bay scallops made it through algae blooms, whelk attacks, underwater landslides and onto dinner tables this season?
Sunrise on Monday, November 6 marked the opening of New York State waters for fishing this sweet local delicacy, and by 7 a.m. it was clear there were plenty of scallops to be harvested.
There are many ways for a scallop to die before its time, and Long Island University biologist Stephen Tettelbach, is familiar with all of them. Mr. Tettlebach is the leader of a scallop restoration project that has helped increase commercial shellfish revenues to the local economy by $8 million since 2006.
He measures the success of the program with data gathered from 20 dive sites in the Peconic Estuary, where he records the number, size and condition of bay scallops using forensic techniques worthy of a medical examiner on a murder case.
A STORY IN EVERY SHELL
A slight ridge indicates the scallop has been affected by some shock, such as an attack by a crab, or a toxic algae bloom. A notch in the edge of the shell is the telltale sign of attempted murder by a whelk.
The position of the scallop’s growth ring indicates its age, but also the speed of growth, and how favorable conditions in the bay have been. Mr. Tettelbach has also documented wintertime mass burials of hibernating scallops when underwater sediments shifted, and the scallops didn’t escape.
On a recent dive, he was joined by Scott Hughes, a Cornell Marine Resources Specialist, and graduate students Marissa Velasquez and Steve Heck. Examining the bay bottom at four scalloping sites — Cedar Light, Sag Harbor, Barcelona and Split Rock — they documented improvements in the density and size of the scallops at those sites over 2016.
“There were a lot of smilers!” Mr. Hughes said, bobbing to the surface at the end of a 10-minute dive in Northwest Harbor. That’s marine-biologist-speak for big, adult scallops opening their shells wide to feed on plankton.
At the Sag Harbor site, Tettelbach surfaced with an 86-millimeter bay scallop in his collection bag, one of the largest he’s ever found. Back on the boat, the team measured and recorded the size and condition of each bi-valve as the boat rocked and the wind blew. Then they threw them back, including the one that was bigger than a baseball.
(Baymen take note.)
A KILLING TIDE
The tiny, tasty shellfish used to be worth $1.5 million a year to the East End commercial fishery. But hard times fell in the mid-1980s, when a devastating brown tide, (an algae bloom fueled by water pollution, especially nitrates and phosphorus associated with human waste) dealt a shocking blow to all shellfish, and particularly the Peconic Bay scallop.
Last week, things were looking up. Shelter Island bayman Steve Lenox, on the way to Northwest Harbor at dawn, remembered opening day in 1985, when he and his brother headed out to toss the first dredge. That year, the much-anticipated first day of fishing was his brother’s birthday, and the dredge came up full of empty shells Mr. Lenox said.
“Everything was dead except the hard clams,” he remembered. “Brown algae had killed everything.”
It was an environmental and economic calamity for the region, but it got the attention of legislators and spurred a number of clean water initiatives aimed at reducing levels of nitrates and phosphates in the estuary and improving water quality. Although there have been other less harmful algae blooms, there has been no repeat of the brown tide in the Peconics since 1995.
No one notices an algae bloom in the bays more than the commercial fishermen who spend time on and in the water. “I can tell by the prop wash,” Mr. Lenox said. “The color of the water coming off the propeller. Used to be, even on the way out to Gardiners Island, the prop wash was the color of coffee most of the way. This year it’s been clear.”
COMING BACK STRONG
In 2006 the restoration program headed by Mr. Tettelbach began to support wild bay scallop populations by planting millions of larval scallops. The program has shown remarkable results, with overall annual Peconic Bay harvests from 2010-2016 coming in nine to 30 times higher than average annual harvests in the decade before the program began.
The Peconic Bay scallop, one of the disappearing foods brought aboard the Slow Food Organization’s “Ark of Taste” — an endangered-species list of American foods — is back on the menus of New York’s fine restaurants, and back on the delivery list for Fresh Direct online grocery customers this fall. Southold Fish Market reports selling over 400 pounds of scallops to Fresh Direct in the first week of the 2017 season.
Scalloping is a hands-on job, and by the end of the day, the culler on a scallop boat has examined every one for size, maturity and liveliness. The work requires expertise in the life cycle of the Peconic Bay scallop, because getting the largest, sweetest, most marketable bivalves depends on understanding the physiological changes that take place over the mollusks’ two-year lifespan.
By November, when the scalloping season opens, the adults have recovered from spawning, developing a deeper and more globe-shaped shell with a slightly raised ring, and are ready to eat. It’s this growth ring that baymen look for when they bring up a dredge-full of scallops.
Juvenile scallops without a growth ring go back into the bay to grow another year and spawn. Scallops spawn once, and the adults die of old age during the winter months, so there is no guilt in eating an adult bay scallop.
BRING ON THE BUGS
The size and number of bug, or juvenile, scallops in the 2016 season was the largest in anybody’s memory, a good sign for the health of the fishery. But the size of the juvenile scallops presented a problem.
“Illegal harvesting of bug scallops may have had significant adverse effects on the scallop population,” Mr. Tettelbach said. “It will likely mean the scallop harvest for the next two seasons will be lower than it might have been otherwise.”
“I heard they were writing a lot of tickets,” said Nate Phillips of Alice’s Fish Market, about DEC efforts to curb illegal fishing of juvenile scallops, efforts that Phillips was glad to see.
At least two of those tickets were issued this past winter to fishermen in the waters off Shelter Island, when New York State Department of Conservation officers determined that 15 percent of their total catch consisted of juvenile scallops. In most years, the DEC does not write a single ticket for illegal fishing of juvenile scallops. In 2016 twice as many tickets were recorded as in any year in a decade.
Last week the season began, with so many baymen bringing in their 10-bushel limit, that Braun Seafood and Southold Fish Market had to deal with an oversupply that strained their ability to shuck and sell the mounds of shellfish. Baymen are reporting that they see very few juvenile scallops, especially compared to last year, confirming what the scientists are seeing.
Once nearly extinct, Peconic Bay scallops are back, providing a winter boost to the East End economy. “Obviously we’d all like to get back to what it was before the brown tide in 1985,” Mr. Tettelbach said. “That’s what we are shooting for.”