06/08/14 8:54pm
Nominee Matt Dunning, left, and winner Drew Garrison of Shelter Island High School. They co-starred in 'Young Frankenstein.' (Credit: Grant Parpan)

Teeny Award nominee Matt Dunning, left, and winner Drew Garrison of Shelter Island High School. They co-starred in ‘Young Frankenstein’ this April. (Credit: Grant Parpan)

Before announcing the two ties at the 12th Annual East End Arts Teeny Awards Sunday afternoon, presenters asked the audience not to clap until both names were read.

But once the large group of Islanders who traveled all the way to Longwood High School for the ceremony heard the name Drew Garrison, they erupted in immediate applause.   (more…)