Reporter’s Photo Quiz: What is that? Nov. 14, 2026

If you know, let us know. Send your responses to [email protected] or phone 631-275-1859. 

Towny Montant knew immediately what last week’s (right) mystery photo was, writing to us: “That would be the heating oil, fuel storage across the street from Piccozzi’s Mobil station (oldest continuously operated Mobil station in USA). Gasoline is stored behind the station underground.” And Jennifer Allen emailed us with the correct identification. 

That iconic Mobil station that Towny referenced is the only gas station left on the Island. In September 2022, we reported: “It’s as much a part of Shelter Island as any landmark, and it’s been there on Bridge Street for 95 years. Recognized as the oldest, family-run Mobil Service Station in the world, Piccozzi’s Service Station was honored with an award from Exxon/Mobil for its ‘dedication to our customers, community and our continued business relationship over the past 95 years.’ In a statement the family said: ‘We thank our founders ‘Jake’ and ‘Augie’ Piccozzi, all our loyal customers, our outstanding employees and our successful partnership with Mobil Oil for this accomplishment.’”

Here’s to another 95 years — at least.