02.06.2026 Featured Story Loss brings tears and growth: Theinerts and friends to celebrate Joey’s 40th “There’s something beautiful that can come out of something awful.” That was James “Jimbo” Theinert speaking this week about the death of his beloved brother, Joey, which would lead...
02.05.2026 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter Community Calendar: Feb. 5, 2026 EVERY WEEK AA meetings: Keep It Simple & Early Birds Meeting in person at 7 a.m, Monday through Friday, 8:30 Saturdays. Wednesdays, 6:30 p.m. Saturdays 7:30 p.m., St. Mary’s...
02.04.2026 Featured Story Shelter Island boys basketball team in final home game of the season Smithtown Christian is one of the top Class D boys basketball teams in League VII. Sporting a 10-6 record, they are headed to the playoffs. When Shelter Island visited...
02.02.2026 Featured Story Souper Bowl of Caring at Shelter Island School The Shelter Island School’s National Honor Society has kicked off the “Souper Bowl of Caring,” an annual drive against hunger in the community. From now until Feb. 6, all...
01.29.2026 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter full obituary: Carol Hallman Carol Hallman, 79, of Shelter Island passed away peacefully at the Kanas East End Hospice Center in Westhampton Beach on Jan. 26, 2026. Carol was born on Sept. 21,...
Shelter Island Reporter
