05.13.2026 Featured Story Prom: A night for Shelter Island School students to remember This year’s prom took place on May 9 at the Shelter Island House. The theme was “A Night in Vegas.” A big credit for the event is due to...
05.13.2026 Featured Story Baseball team undefeated: 5-0 in stellar ‘26 season After a short break in their schedule, the Shelter Island Boys Baseball team got right back to work, sweeping the Pierson Whalers in two straight games on Tuesday, May...
05.05.2026 Featured Story News from Goat Hill: Club opens season with course upgrades Now in its 125th year, the Shelter Island Country Club (SICC), affectionately known as Goat Hill, continues to play a central role in the Shelter Island community. Last weekend,...
05.05.2026 Uncategorized Fireworks Committee seeks community support: ‘Dire situation’ in funding It was nearly a decade ago, when Brett Surerus was on the South Ferry reading the Reporter, when he learned the Shelter Island Chamber of Commerce had canceled the...
04.21.2026 Featured Story Island baseball team undefeated in first week of play As cleats click against the concrete floor of the dugout and players hold their gloves in hand, Fiske Field is filled with baseball players from early March through late...
Shelter Island Reporter
