Shelter Island Reporter Real Estate Transfers: Sept. 24, 2026
Listings prepared for Times Review Media Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., dated July 24, 2026 .
SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS (11965)
• 5 Grand Ave LLC to Erin Loughran, 5 Grand Avenue (700-5-5-20.001) (R) $1,999,999
• Jeanne & Thomas Magno and Joseph & Kathleen Smith to Allen Ricca & Caylin Jensen, 30 Brander Parkway (700-21-1-58) (R) $1,450,000
AQUEBOGUE (11931)
• Ford Kimmel to Jorge Rivas & Evelia Sanchez, 133 Trout Brook Lane (600-85-2-95.038) (R) $780,000
• Markan LLC to Vallace Family Trust, 84 Crystal Drive (600-67-2-16.034) (R) $750,000
CUTCHOGUE (11935)
• Roy Ward to Christopher & Sandra Zander, 4075 Stillwater Avenue (1000-137-1-8.001) (R) $4,725,000
• Eric & Jamie Webber to Michael & Rachel Berick 350 Eastwood Drive (1000-110-3-14) (R) $1,440,000
• John & Kathleen Spicer to Marian Robinson & Susan Vahrenkamp, 29 Sweet Meadow Court (1000-102.01-1-31) (R) $1,100,000
• Jane Bieneman & Gianfranco Mitrione to Leo K Group LLC, 10100 New Suffolk Avenue (1000-116-6-1.002) (R) $995,000
• Fief De Freeman LLC to North Fork Holdings Group LLC, 28785 Main Road (1000-102-5-23) (C) $800,000
• Hartmann Trust to Victoria Hawkins, 33780 Main Road (1000-97-2-12.001) (R) $720,000
• Stoutenburgh Trust to William Roth Trust & Debra Roth, 3790 Skunk Lane (1000-97-8-30.001) (V) $250,000
GREENPORT (11944)
• Mehmet Sengulen to Rodger Greenport LLC, 123 Sterling Avenue Unit J (1001-3.02-1-10) (R) $1,600,000
• Chad Somodi & Melissa Flores to Kevin Plattenburg & Kathryn Newhouse, 155 Bridge Street (1000-34-3-45) (R) $1,470,000
• Juliet Weber to James & Katie Kozma, 604 Main Street (1001-3-4-2) (R) $1,300,000
• Thomas DeWolfe to 415 Sterling LLC, 115 Sterling Place (1000-34-3-50.001) (R) $605,000
JAMESPORT (11947)
• Southampton Building Company Corp to 62 Tuthills Lane LLC, 62 Tuthills Lane (600-68-1-10.003) (V) $1,875,000
• Celia Iannelli to Evan Kappenberg, 108 Vista Court (600-94-1-3.010) (R) $800,000
• Bruce & Marybeth Roehrig to Daniel & Victoria Pilo, 93 Saint Marys Drive (600-69-3-26) (R) $800,000
• Speonk Land Development LLC to Southampton Building Company Corp, 62 Tuthills Lane (600-68-1-10.003) (V) $400,000
LAUREL (11948)
• Daniel & Joi Murray to 5218 MRV LLC, 5218 Peconic Bay Blvd (1000-128-2-22) (R) $2,612,500
MATTITUCK (11952)
• Estate of Anne Renganeschi & Frederick Renganeschi to Thomas & Rosellen Panissidi, 2005 Westview Drive (1000-107-7-4) (R) $1,600,000
• Carol Bowden to Salvatore & Desiree Liggieri, 750 Mayflower Road (1000-107-8-25) (R) $845,000
• Estate of Kathleen McAteer to James Wightman, 770 Meadow Lane (1000-115-4-28) (R) $822,000
• Jayme Figurny to Michael Figurney 1525 Bergen Avenue (1000-112-1-16.007) (R) 525,000
• David & Jean Oddon to Dylan Tobias & Rachel Wells, 655 Legion Avenue (1000-142-2-5) (R) $525,000
PECONIC (11958)
• Salt Marsh Lane LLC to Suffolk Land Holdings LLC, 430 Salt Marsh Lane (1000-68-3-13) (R) $2,375,000
RIVERHEAD (11901)
• Pamela & Susan Gatz & Patricia Kasold to County of Suffolk, 500 Cross River Drive (600-112-2-1.001) (V) $1,269,450
• Barbara Cusumano & Zafer Kakanas to Thomas & Andrea Newman, 390 Stonecrop Road (600-45-6-59) (R) $865,000
• George & Yvonne Yakaboski to Angel Davila & Rosa Vargas, 817 Pondview Road (600-126-2-24.002) (R) $815,000
• Hamilton Avenue Property LLC to 303 Raynor Avenue LLC, 303 Raynor Avenue (600-124-1-22) (C) $420,000
• Estate of Hester Taylor to 607 Osborn Ave LLC, 607 Osborn Avenue (600-123-3-28) (R) $400,000
• RJB Peconic Corp to Benchmark Construction Management LLC, 54 Tyler Drive (600-64-1-6.025) (V) $300,000
• Benchmark Construction Management LLC to William Moreno & Jennifer Weston, 54 Tyler Drive (600-64-1-6.025) (V) $275,000
SOUTHOLD (11971)
• 600 Glenn LLC to Reinhold Tremba & Stefka Nazarkewycz, 600 Glenn Road (1000-78-2-24) (R) $1,950,000
(Key: Tax map numbers = District-Section-Block-Lot; (A) = agriculture; (R) = residential; (V) = vacant property; (C) = commercial; (R&E) = recreation & entertainment; (CS) = community services; (I) = industrial; (PS) = public service; (P) = park land; as determined from assessed values in the current tax rolls.)
