Town Board issues guidance on immigration arrests
At the Town Board’s Nov. 17 work session, Councilwoman Liz Hanley laid out what the Town’s actions would be if federal immigration agents are arresting people on the Island.
She spoke about the concern and confusion that many Islanders experienced when they learned that Hugo Leonel Ardon Osorio, an employee at Marcello Masonry, was arrested in the Greenport’s North Ferry line by Immigration Customs and Enforcement (ICE) on an early February morning this year. After a grueling 23 days in custody, he was released. Bobby Marcello, owner of Marcello Masonry had hired an attorney to plead the case for Mr. Ardon Osorio’s release.
Two other long-time Greenport residents were arrested around the same time on immigration charges, and in February 2025 federal officers were on the streets of Greenport. They stopped people and went into a laundromat on a Sunday morning, questioning people at random doing their laundry, and arrested two individuals.
Protecting vulnerable residents from actions that ICE could employ here and have used in other communities around the country is a goal, but Ms. Hanley said that the Board is not in favor of legislation proposed by OLA (Organización Latino Americana) to counter ICE presence. Two East End towns, East Hampton Town and East Hampton Village, chose to incorporate Gov. Kathy Hochul’s (D) ban of cooperation with ICE, maintaining it would strengthen their stance against federal immigration practices.
A Shelter Island Public Safety Task Force was formed, which included Police Chief Jim Read, Supervisor Amber Brach-Williams, Ms. Hanley, Victoria Shields and Gina Kraus, and has put together a document on “guidance” for Town officials to act in a situation involving ICE agents arresting and/or detaining people.
The guidance that Town officials will follow begins when there are reports of an immigration crackdown by federal agents. A police supervisor will be notified as soon as possible, and all available information will be “evaluated and forwarded to the police chief.” This step of evaluating information is critical, Ms. Hanley said, since misinformation can circulate quickly.
Then, according to the guidance policy, “The Chief or designee reviews the available information as soon as practicable, including the nature of the activity, whether it involves civil immigration enforcement or a criminal law enforcement matter, and any public safety or operational concerns.”
The next step is the Town Board — whose members are the Police Commissioners — is informed of any actions on the Island. Direct contact will ensure, the document states, that all members receive the same available information in a timely manner. “But this notification may be delayed, limited, or withheld,” the document states, “when it could compromise an active criminal investigation, criminal warrant, planned law enforcement operation, or the confidentiality of law enforcement information, or jeopardize officers or public safety.”
The Town social worker is then brought into the response. The social worker will have contacts with community organizations as well as the Island churches to get the word out about people being detained so family members, especially children, can be notified and cared for, Ms. Hanley said.
The final step in the process is communicating to the public at large “when appropriate and when the information can safely be released,” according to the document.
Budget 2027
The Town Board finalized the 2027 budget at a special meeting during its work session on Nov. 17.
Ms. Brach-Williams, Deputy Supervisor Meg Larsen and Ms. Hanley voted unanimously to adopt the budget. They were the only three members casting votes, with Councilman Albert Dickson retired as of Nov. 1 and Councilman Ben Dyett absent.
The budget will remain at a 4.4% increase over the current budget, as was reported a week ago. The biggest component of the Town budget is personnel costs, for a total of $8,114,755 representing 42% of total appropriations, and 2.7% of the total budget increase. Employee benefit costs encompassing retirement, health insurance and payroll taxes, and insurance are a large part of the 2027 budget. These costs total $5,807,945 or 30% of total appropriations.
Skate Park
The Board heard from Kate Rossi-Snook and Joe Denny, members of the nonprofit Kids In Motion, which also includes Mark Thackrah, Judith Lechmanski and Frank Kestler. This group has been tasked to overhaul the skate park on Bowditch Road, which Ms. Rossi-Snook noted was in serious disrepair.

She said it was an important recreation site for people of all ages and also a place for kids to socially interact. Presently, the park “needs some love,” she added and that the skate park was mentioned for review in the proposed Town Comprehensive Plan, .
There has been a positive response to plans to restore the park from community members, including neighbors on Bowditch Road, Ms. Rossi-Snook said, and also calls to move the facility to a location in the Center near the rest of the playgrounds and sports areas.
The proposed park would be 179 feet by 49 feet and is estimated to cost a total of $400,000, but Ms. Rossi-Snook said after the meeting that “we anticipate it costing less than that. We’re hoping it will be a combination of individual community donations and grants. Any surplus funds raised will be rolled over to future projects.”
If all goes well, Mr. Denny said, some funding could come from a New York State grant.
Ms. Brach-Williams said the Board at present is taking a wait-and-see stance on the project.

