Shelter Island real estate transfers, July 2m 2026

Listings prepared for Times Review Media Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., dated April 24, 2026.

SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS (11965)

• Carolyn Demarest and Nelson & Jonathan Demarest to David & Tiffany Rolfe, 6A South Ram Island Drive, (700-11-2-2.002) (R) $4,100,000

• Diane Smith to Edmund Dandridge and Suzanne Shaker, 10A Hillcrest Road, (700-21-1-36.001) (V) $230,000

AQUEBOGUE (11931)

• Estate of Julia Cooper to Carly Postal, 72 Josica Drive, (600-85-4-21) (R) $655,000 

• Beverly Buckingham and Karen & Ann Raffel to Jamesport Farmhouse LLC, 1197 Main Road, (600-68-3-5.002) (R) $615,000

CUTCHOGUE (11935)

• Joseph Fuchs to John & Diane Hodgson, 1070 Depot Lane, (1000-102-2-6.002) (R) $1,449,000

• Matthew & Diane Bassford and Maude Carter to Integrity Equity Partners LLC, 34100 Route 25, (1000-97-2-10.001) (R) $519,000

EAST MARION (11939)

• Vito Tanzi and Lena Trieu-Tanzi to Kimberly Hourihan and Carol Morris, 3345 Cedar Lane, (1000-37-7-10.002)(R) $4,825,000

• Estate of Florence Mazurowski to Frank & Pamela Hoerauf, 11005 Main Road, (1000-31-4-29) (R) $650,000

FISHERS ISLAND (06390)

• Carp & Bird LLC to Nicholas & Katherine Beardsley, 810 Equestrian Avenue, (1000-9-4-11.005) (C) $525,000

• James Mannetti to CG Old North LLC, Avenue B, (1000-6-2-20) (V) $360,000

GREENPORT (11944)

• Victoria Chute to Michael Flora, 1295 Washington Avenue Extension, (1000-41-2-6) (R) $630,000

• Leland & Linda Denny to Nicholas Ritacco-Canessa, 280 Champlin Place, (1000-34-3-42) (R) $410,000

JAMESPORT (11947)

• Bart & Karen Badalucco to Craig & Danica Calderone, 7 Eileen Circle, (600-47-3-1.025) (R) $840,000

LAUREL (11948)

• Ronald McCaskie to Christopher & Stephanie Kugler and Richard & Kathleen Kugler, 2360 Peconic Bay Blvd, (1000-128-6-16) (R) $943,260 

• Thomas Coticchio Trust to Steven & Holly Ficner, 4045 Delmar Drive, (1000-125-4-1) (R) $787,500

MATTITUCK (11952)

• Bruce Vitale to 7280 Sound Avenue LLC, 7280 Sound Avenue, (1000-121-5-2) (C) $1,950,000

• Robert & Ileesa Engel to Victoria & Paul Fogarty, 305 Fay Court, 1000-123-5-36.010) (R) $1,650,000

SOUTHOLD (11971)

• Marratime Capital V LLC to Alan & Annie Omens, 1955 Laurel Avenue, (1000-56-1-1.001) (R) $2,400,000

• Ioannis Zoumas to Nicholas & Jessica Marino, 285 Blue Marlin Drive, (1000-57-1-45) (R) $2,225,000

• Thomas & Lori Ruthinoski to Ann Marchese and Philip Patti, 1755 Yennecott Drive, (1000-55-4-21) (R) $940,000

• Ahmad-Ali Sardar-Afkhami to Mohamad Sardar, 44190 Route 25, (1000-75-6-6.002) (R) $400,000

(Key: Tax map numbers = District-Section-Block-Lot; (A) = agriculture; (R) = residential; (V) = vacant property; (C) = commercial; (R&E) = recreation & entertainment; (CS) = community services; (I) = industrial; (PS) = public service; (P) = park land; as determined from assessed values in the current tax rolls.)