Gone Fishing: What makes a season successful?
Somewhere between winterizing boats and freezing the last of this season’s catch, this is the time of year when anglers start to reflect. With the end of the East End’s saltwater fishing season in sight, many anglers are looking back on their time on the water in 2026 with the same question: Was it a good season?
The answer depends on who you ask.
Some anglers spend an entire season in pursuit of a singular fish. For many of the striped bass enthusiasts I know, their season’s success often depends on the landing of a fish in the 50 pound range. Others are happy catching whatever happens to bite.
Either way, a successful season is about much more than the amount of fish in your freezer or the pictures you’ve posted on social media. Sometimes, the most meaningful progress comes from the trips when you return to the dock empty-handed.
Sure, having quality gear is important, but it doesn’t automatically lead to success. Consistency in catching is what differentiates an angler from the rest of the fleet. Some of the most renowned captains I’ve met are considered “good” not because of the price of their gear, but because of the understanding of fisheries they’ve built over time. The fishermen who keep learning and adapting give themselves the best chance of keeping up.
I was reminded of this over the summer, when I befriended a crew of anglers in search of their first bluefin tuna. The thought of bringing home a tuna is an exciting prospect to any angler, and this group was no different. They made roughly half a dozen trips, with the first five resulting in nothing but empty coolers. Finally, on their last trip of the season, they brought home a bluefin. On paper, one tuna in six trips might not sound particularly impressive, but having seen what went into that fish, I’d argue otherwise.
On their first attempt, they left the dock about an hour after sunrise. By the time they reached the tuna grounds, the morning bite was long over. They returned home with a fuel gauge much lower than when they had left and ice you could put in a cocktail. But they also obtained important information: a feeding window can be brief, and arriving after it closes can make for a very long boat ride home.
They wasted no time in adapting, and on the following trip they made it to the tuna grounds right on time. Expecting at least a shot at a tuna, they were thoroughly disappointed when they were met with a tuna fisherman’s worst fear: a seemingly lifeless stretch of ocean. No boats, no birds, no whales or dolphins, and, apparently, no tuna.
They were frustrated, understandably.
One challenge for anyone learning about a fishery is getting useful information. Fishermen, myself included, can be protective of productive spots and bites. One might consider that selfish, but information travels quickly in the fishing world. A bite you had almost to yourself one afternoon can become a parking lot the next morning. Somehow, the two people you told have turned into 50 boats, and everyone seems equally surprised to see you.
Still, there’s a difference between needing someone’s exact coordinates and getting a general understanding of where fish and bait have been concentrated. Well-known grounds south of Montauk and across the broader midshore waters, including CIA, the Butterfish Hole, and the Coimbra, are an excellent starting points for novice anglers. Not only are they easy to find with the large fleets that congregate around them, but they can hold fish for extended periods. This crew learned that without recent reports, last week’s location wasn’t enough to build tomorrow’s trip around.
Eventually, in mid-August, they caught wind of a solid ongoing bluefin bite.
I was aboard for that trip. It was as early as first light that the lessons learned started to show. For the first time, the crew saw what true “tuna life” was. Tuna chicks (birds that feed on the same fish as tuna), a slick, and a group of feeding humpback whales surrounded the boat.
For tuna fisherman, this is a feeling like waking up as a kid on Christmas morning.
The biggest present under the tree, however, were the long streaks of red that started to appear on the fish finder. I murmured “there’s no shot we don’t get tight here.”
And like clockwork, a rod doubled over and the sound of ecstatic anglers filled the boat.
The shouting, celebrating, and sheer joy of the moment reminded me why I love fishing in the first place.
Unfortunately, as happens so often when tuna fishing, we were humbled. While I was at the helm, the drag was tightened, and the hook pulled.
The boat went silent. After all those early mornings, gallons of gas burned, and silent rides back to the dock, they had finally hooked their tuna – and lost it.
Before anyone had much chance to dwell on it, I brought us around for another drift.
Tuna fishing can be cruel. Some days, you don’t mark a fish. Other days, the fish gods seem willing to give you chance after chance. Fortunately for us, they were feeling generous that day.
Before I could finish explaining how to avoid what had happened during the previous fight, someone yelled, “We’re on!”
I looked over to see line peeling off the reel and a crew that had sprung back to life.
This time, the drag stayed where it was. After a 20-minute battle, we boated a 44-inch bluefin.
On paper, this is nothing more than the average recreational bluefin. But measuring that fish in inches hardly captured what it meant to the people standing around it.
They had done what every successful tuna crew must learn to do: push through frustration and take the lessons they learned back onto the water and put them to use.
That made them, in my eyes, one of the most successful crews I encountered this season.
As anglers we have the freedom to measure a season by more than numbers and size. Catching fish matters, of course. We wouldn’t put so much effort into it otherwise. But so does making the most of the time we have on the water.
So, before deciding whether this was a good season, think beyond the fish you brought home or the photographs on your phone.
What do you understand now that you didn’t in the spring? What would you do differently? And when the same opportunity comes around next season, how will you be better prepared?
For that crew, the answer to whether this was a good season was a resounding yes. Their long-awaited sushi dinner was the proof.

