Off-Island students could attend school here: Districts explore options on possible win-win decision
Students at Oysterponds Elementary School may soon have another option for their secondary education. The Shelter Island School District is exploring the possibility of welcoming students from the neighboring district beginning in 7th grade.
The potential partnership was a topic of discussion at the Nov. 18 Shelter Island Board of Education meeting, where Superintendent Brian Doelger, Ed.D. updated the Board on recent conversations with Oysterponds School District officials. Currently, Oysterponds students attend secondary school at the Greenport Union Free School District after completing 7th grade. Oysterponds School covers grades Pre-K through 6th grade for residents of East Marion and Orient. However, the district is exploring alternative options for its secondary students, and Shelter Island has emerged as a potential choice.
Mr. Doelger said he and the district’s business consultant, Sam Schneider, visited Oysterponds School two weeks ago to discuss the possibility. This week, the Oysterponds superintendent and three members of its Board of Education visited the Island School for a tour of the building, facilities and academic programs.
“We had an excellent visit with them,” Mr. Doelger said, adding that it is an attractive idea to bring additional tax revenue here from outside the community.
The prospect of Oysterponds students attending Shelter Island has been looked at in the past, but it seems there’s currently growing interest once again, Mr. Doelger said. “They were blown away,” Board President Kathleen M. Lynch said, describing the reaction to the school’s facilities and programs.
Oysterponds Elementary School has approximately 100 students district-wide, with its secondary student population totaling about 40. Mr. Doelger emphasized that the district is not seeking an exclusive arrangement, but rather the opportunity to become an option for Oysterponds families. “If something like that could work out, it would really be a home run all around,” he told the Board. “We’re definitely going to continue to pursue that and see where that takes us.”
Old and young together
Another major focus of the superintendent’s report was the district’s growing effort to strengthen its relationship with Shelter Island’s senior citizens. Mr. Doelger reported on a recent meeting involving representatives from the Senior Center, the Senior Foundation, Town officials, community members and representatives from East End Health. The group discussed ways the school could create more meaningful connections between students and older residents.
The district has already begun putting some of those ideas into action, sending a group of students to have lunch with senior citizens at the Presbyterian Church. One idea under consideration is establishing a program in which high school students could assist seniors with everyday technology needs, such as setting up email accounts, troubleshooting televisions and handling other simple technical tasks.
”We obviously want to have meaningful connections and we look forward to this developing even more,” he said.
In Other News
Assistant Principal Sean Brennan highlighted the school’s Veterans Day activities, thanking
Commander Mundy at the American Legion and Jim Colligan for helping organize educational opportunities for students. High school students in grades 9 through 12 also heard from Mr. Colligan about his service in Vietnam. They also visited the American Legion, where they participated in a scavenger hunt and learned about military artifacts and the history of residents who served.
Middle school students in grades 6 through 8 visited the Legion to learn about flag etiquette and proper flag folding as they prepared for the Veterans Day ceremony. Students also helped replace older flags on veterans’ graves with new ones, an activity Mr. Brennan said gave them an opportunity to participate directly in honoring Island veterans. He praised the Legion and the staff members who helped make the day possible, describing it as a meaningful way for students to recognize Veterans Day while strengthening their connection to the history of their hometown.
Assistant Superintendent Jennifer Rylott updated the board on recent discussions by the New York State Board of Regents regarding graduation requirements and Regents examinations. Following stakeholder feedback, the State has adjusted its original proposal, with Regents examinations now expected to continue through 2030. However, questions remain about whether the examinations will continue to be required for graduation or whether districts will eventually be permitted to use alternative assessments.
Ms. Rylott said she was seeking additional clarification and would continue updating the board as the State works through the proposal.
Mr. Doelger officially welcomed Daniela Chavez to the district. Ms. Chavez has been working as a bilingual aide while also providing classroom support. “She’s doing a great job,” he said. “We’re very happy to have her here as part of our school community.”
The superintendent also reflected on several recent school activities, including a successful student trip to Disney, Halloween celebrations and a professional development day for teachers. He also praised the Student Council for its inclusive Halloween activities and the PTSA and parent volunteers for organizing the school’s annual Trunk-Or-Treat event.
The district’s recent teacher conference day, held on Election Day, was also recognized for its combination of professional development, collaboration and team-building activities. Additionally, the members of then Perlman Music Program visited the school and performed for elementary students. Mr. Doelger praised the musicians for their dedication and noted that students learned about the commitment and practice required to develop such musical prowess.
As the meeting concluded, the superintendent wished the school community a restful Thanksgiving holiday, with school scheduled to close Wednesday through Friday of next week.

