Islander robbed of $80,000 in scam gets it back
A Shelter Island resident recently got justice. And stolen funds returned.
Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney announced this week that an elderly Islander in September found that a transfer of $80,000 of his money was unauthorized and the funds wired to an out-of-state credit union.
Recognizing the discrepancies, the Islander got in touch with the Shelter Island Police Department, the D.A. said. SIPD detectives immediately contacted the credit union to reserve the funds. Officers also contacted the D.A.’s Financial Crime Bureau to serve subpoenas for records to find where the funds were deposited, the D.A. said.
Because of the quick action by the two agencies, the funds were frozen by the credit union, which then started its own investigation. “Prosecutors confirmed that the fraudulent account was closed and all funds were returned to the Shelter Island victim as the rightful owner,” the D.A. said.
“One of the most critical actions a victim of a scam or financial crime can take is reporting the incident to law enforcement as soon as possible,” said SIPD Det. Sgt. Jack Thilberg. “Early notification provides investigators with the best opportunity to track fraudulent transactions, identify those responsible, and work with financial institutions and partner agencies to pursue recovery of stolen funds. Unfortunately, delays in reporting often reduce the chances of restitution, since funds can be quickly moved through a complex network of accounts and jurisdictions.”
Det Thilberg added, “If something feels suspicious or doesn’t seem right, trust your instincts. Take a moment to pause, discuss the situation with a trusted friend or family member, and contact law enforcement immediately. Early reporting can be critical to protecting your finances and improving the chances of a successful investigation and recovery of your loss.”

