12.16.2025 Featured Story Cornucopia shares its final gifts: Memories and friendships made down a quiet lane “I just want to say thank you,” is the first comment from Mary Lou Eichhorn on her impending retirement from Cornucopia, fittingly thinking of others, as a shop devoted...
12.10.2025 Featured Story Shelter Island’s Cornucopia shop to close doors Mary Lou Eichhorn has shared the news that her unique gift shop, Cornucopia, will close its doors on Dec. 30 after 45 years. Until then, Mary Lou will be...
04.29.2025 Featured Story Jenifer’s Shelter Island Journal: Gifted When I asked Mary Lou Eichhorn, proprietor of the iconic Island gift shop, Cornucopia, for an interview this week, I knew it wouldn’t be her first rodeo — hardly....
02.06.2025 Featured Story Where to shop, where to eat on Shelter Island for the perfect Valentine’s Day Islanders know that even in the middle of quiet February, our unique shops are well-stocked with gifts that say, “You are special.” Cornucopia — 631-749-0171 — Mary Lou Eichhorn...
08.30.2024 Featured Story Happy Birthday, Mary Lou Many Islanders who appreciate Mary Lou Eichhorn’s advice on finding the perfect birthday cards and presents at her Cornucopia shop returned the favor on Friday, Aug. 23 by surprising...
Shelter Island Reporter
