Featured Story
02/27/19 8:00am


The Shelter Island political season got off to an early start — eight months before Election Day — with the Shelter Island Democratic Committee announcing its 2019 slate of candidates for supervisor, Town Board members, and highway superintendent. (more…)

Featured Story
10/31/18 8:00am

Part of the bipartisan group protesting in the Center in October 2016 over the theft and destruction of political lawn signs.

As the November 6 election approaches, there are complaints of lawn signs being stolen or vandalized around the Island. Leaders of both political parties have taken stands against such actions, but the problem has persisted, they say. (more…)

Featured Story
10/28/16 2:00pm


To the Editor:
Through the process of reviewing the DJTM Enterprises vetting process, everyone who signed a petition opposing the company’s affordable housing proposal was well informed on the Community Housing Board activities prior to signing. Hundreds of people who live on the Island became better informed about the floating zone and what its impact could have been on the northern section of Route 114 on a one-third acre parcel. (more…)

09/18/13 2:03pm

COURTESY PHOTO | Robert Reylek said he’s running for a Town Board seat to support Supervsior Jim Dougherty and bring a more civil tone to Town Hall.

Democrat Robert Reylek is running for a seat on the Town Board to bring a liberal voice to Shelter Island’s government.

Mr. Reylek is challenging two long-time Town Board incumbents, Chris Lewis, running on the Republican and Conservative tickets, and Ed Brown, who is on the Conservative line. In a three-way election, if Mr. Reylek — who also has the Independence and Working Families lines — can summon enough votes to come in second or first on November 5, he can begin to put his ideas into action January 1. A third place finish for the Democrat means the incumbents remain in place.

Mr. Reylek agreed with one opponent, Ms. Lewis, on the so-called “dark skies” legislation, a contentious issue debated for months and passed in July regulating commercial and residential outdoor lighting. Ms. Lewis was a strong advocate for the law.

But he said aside from dark skies, “I haven’t really followed how she’s come down on other issues.”

There was no equivocation when it came to squaring off with Mr. Brown, however, who voted against the local lighting law. He was opposed to it on several counts; one important objection he voiced is it was another example of government overreaching its responsibilities, he said.

“I’m a lot more liberal than he is,” Mr. Reylek said. “I think government can be a good thing. Not all regulation is bad.”

Mr. Brown said Mr. Reylek is correct that he is more liberal. But his challenger is wrong that the incumbent believes all regulation is bad, Mr. Brown said. He added that residents should look at his record on votes he’s cast for “substantial environmental controls, code updating and general regulations necessary to successfully run the town. I’ve been consistent in my philosophy not to over regulate.”

Mr. Reylek also said he was running to ensure fellow Democrat Supervisor Jim Dougherty can rely on him for support. Mr. Dougherty and Democrat Highway Superintendent Jay Card are both running unopposed.

Seeing his candidacy as an opportunity to increase voter turnout, Mr. Reylek said “we need some competition in this election or nobody would be voting at all,” he said.

He’s the husband of Heather Reylek, chairwoman of the Shelter Island Democratic Committee. He said he didn’t jump at the chance to run for Town Board. “There was a lot of thought involved,” he said.

This isn’t Mr. Reyleks’ first town-wide election, serving 21 years on the Shelter Island School Board, 19 of them as president. Name recognition with the voters won’t be a problem because of his service on the school board, he said. “I know I’ve made some enemies, especially being president,” Mr. Reylek added. “It will help with name recognition. It’s better than having no name recognition.”

He’s currently vice president of the Lions Club, is a director for the Shelter Island Association and owner of the local general contracting company, Robert Reylek, Inc.

He’d been approached by residents asking him to run, he said, because they thought it was time for a change on the board. “People have been there a long time,” Mr. Reylek said.

Mr. Brown was appointed to the board in 2001 and has served ever since and Ms. Lewis was first elected to the board 11 years ago.
“I don’t think being in too long is a bad thing unless you’ve been a bad performer,” Ms. Lewis said. “ If you’re doing a good job, balancing a budget and you’re responsive to the electorate and giving the town your undivided attention, then I don’t think it matters.”

Mr. Reylek said it was also time “to change the tenor of the Town Board. Sometimes they’re not polite with each other. People who have spoken to me said that should change.”