03.10.2026 Featured Story New superintendent at Shelter Island Country Club One of the highest points on the Island, Goat Hill, has been the scene of delighted gatherings in the wake of recent heavy snows, as it’s famed for being...
05.28.2025 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter Profile: Dave McGayhey, protecting and defending the Island since 1985 There have been two homicides in Shelter Island history and in his 40 years of service, Police Officer David McGayhey responded to both. When he was off-duty one day...
Shelter Island Reporter
