Island Profile | Retiring Fire Marshal Mike looks back
This year, 2026, is the last round of fire safety talks for Mike Johnson, Shelter Island’s beloved “Fire Marshal Mike” and the question he got from a Shelter Island 3rd-grader in one of his final sessions made him proud and happy for the impact he has had.
She raised a hand and asked, “Fire Marshal Mike, how would a pregnant woman get out of the window?”
Mike has been teaching school children the safest way to get out of a burning building for four decades, including a window technique that involves hanging facing the sill to reduce the distance you fall.
“That was the first time in my 38 years, I was asked that,” Mike said, and since the 3rd-grade teacher was also interested in the answer, he demonstrated how to push a table in front of your window, get on the table, turn around 180 degrees, and back out, potentially saving two generations of Islanders from fire.
The young are not the only ones to benefit from the fire safety education Mike has shared. He has spoken to many senior groups and church groups, but teaching children is his first love, especially after he learned how to use puppets to reach his youngest students.
While attending a fire prevention safety course one day, he sat in on a talk about using puppets, and was initially very skeptical, but found it worked. “I started with Fireman Frankie. He’s the big one in the middle with the red mouth. Then Sam, the Smoke Detector — he yells a lot. I have Samantha, who was Frank’s girlfriend, and her parents, Mr. and Mrs. Parker. All the puppets are named after fire marshals I’ve worked with.”
Mike Johnson was the youngest child of his family, born in Flushing, Queens, where he grew up with his brother, Gene and sister, Peggy. His grandparents had been spending summers on Shelter Island since 1936, and Mike soon became a permanent fixture in the summer life of the Island during, arguably, its most idyllic chapter. In his day, packs of children roamed the Island, especially the children of Westmoreland, swimming, boating, clamming, tromping through fields and woods and occasionally showing up at each other’s homes to be fed.
Mike remembers the moment when he realized that there was something special about life here. It came at the end of the summer of 1967 during a touch football game at the top of the hill where the Prospect Hotel once stood.
“The friends I had at that time, we just all stuck together,” Mike remembered. “Even though we knew we wouldn’t see each other for almost nine months, we had those two and a half months that we were together.”
He met his wife Gillian when he worked at her family’s home in Westmoreland. “I was picking up her garbage in 1972,” he said, “and we got married 4th of July in ‘73.” They were together for over 40 years.
After a long, successful career as Director of Development and government professor at St. John’s University, Mike and Gillian, a first-grade teacher, decided to spend more time on the Island that they both loved so much. Mike became a fire marshal for the town of East Hampton.
“Part of being a fire marshal, is fire safety education, and I started to work with the schools there, under Fire Chief Andy Steinmuller, who has since passed away,” he said.
In 1988, when Mike and Gillian moved to Shelter Island fulltime, Fred Ogar invited him to come to a meeting, where he was immediately made a member of the Shelter Island Fire Department. He became a fire marshal in 1989 and was named Firefighter of the Year in 1996 and 2017.
Even with the loss of Gillian five years ago, and a cancer diagnosis this past April, Mike considers himself a fortunate man. His prostate cancer led to two months of radiation therapy and hormonal treatments. “The radiation wasn’t bad, but the estrogen hormones that I have to take …” he said. “I am very sympathetic to women now regarding hot flashes. You know, men joke about it, but it’s not really a joke.”
Mike may have stepped down as fire marshal, but he’ll never stop educating people on fire safety. His puppets are at the ready in his living room, and he’s on a mission to let people know how to protect themselves and their families from fires caused by lithium batteries.
“Read the instructions and follow them,” he said. “And that’s how I teach the kids. You may not want to. But if you don’t follow those instructions, we may have a problem. Maintenance. That’s the other word. That is a 3rd-grade vocabulary word. You have to maintain your equipment.”
Lightning Round — Mike Johnson
What do you always have with you? My rosary.
Favorite place on Shelter Island? Everyplace on Shelter Island is my favorite place.
Favorite place not on Shelter Island? The Queen Elizabeth II, docked in Quebec during a cruise with my wife. Over the years, we took 27 cruises together.
When was the last time you were elated? When St. John’s made the Final Four in ’85
When was the last time you were afraid? When my brother, Gene Johnson was stationed in Vietnam in ’67, ‘68. He passed away two months ago, the result of Agent Orange.
Favorite sports/teams? Basketball/St. John’s
What is the best day of the year on Shelter Island? The fireworks, and that’s coming from a fire marshal.
Favorite movie or book? ‘The Day the Earth Stood Still,’ 1951, with Michael Rennie and Patricia Neal.
Favorite food? Chicken parmesan.
Favorite person, living or dead, who is not a member of the family? Nanette Lawrenson, she’s done a helluva job with the Historical Society.
Most respected elected official? Gov. Hugh Carey. The only problem I ever had with him was when he’d land in a helicopter at his house, which was 400 yards from my bedroom window.

