Featured Story

Shelter Island Police Department blotter: Nov. 18, 2026

Those named in arrest reports or receiving police summonses have not been convicted of a crime. In court, the charges against them may be reduced or withdrawn or the defendants may be found not guilty.

SUMMONSES

Walter A. Lemus Perez of Greenport received a summons on Nov. 9 on North Ferry for nontransparent side windows.

Francisco J. Acosta of Wyandanch was ticketed on Nov. 10 on New York Avenue for speeding 38 mph in a 25-mph zone.

Mary T. Massey of Southampton received a summons on Nov. 10 on Manwaring Road for using a cellphone while driving.

Michael C. Shatken of Shelter Island was ticketed on Nov. 10 for an uninspected vehicle.

OTHER REPORTS

Police responded to a complaint on Nov. 11 of duck hunters operating within 500 yards of a Coecles Harbor property. Investigation found that scallop dredging was taking place, not hunting. The complainant was notified and satisfied.

A report of young people screaming was investigated on Nov. 11; young people were found to be playing video games.

Fraudulent banking activity was reported on Nov. 6. Traffic stops were conducted on Nov. 7 (2), 8 (2), 9 (2), 10 (3), and 11 (3) with 11 warnings in addition to the tickets listed.

A residential burglary in Menantic was reported on Nov. 8. Radar enforcement was conducted in the Heights on Nov. 10. An investigation into a case of possession of stolen property was opened on Nov. 12.

In other reports, officers returned property to the owner; responded to accidental 911 calls; conducted well-being checks; assisted with a vehicle lockout; investigated an open door; provided lift assists; performed court duty; responded to an easement dispute; performed school crossing duty; and conducted an administrative audit.

ANIMAL INCIDENTS

An unknown animal was reported on the beach in West Neck on Nov. 8. The Animal Control Officer located a decomposing deer carcass. The Highway Department was notified for removal.

Responding to a report of a buck stuck in a net in the Heights on the 12th, Police Officer McEnroe and the ACO freed the deer. 

The ACO assisted with returning dogs at large to their owners.

ALARMS

Police responded to a smoke alarm activation in the Center on Nov. 7. Shelter Island Fire Department investigated and stated it was a false alarm. Police officers notified the home owner and all parental guardians of those on the scene.

A residential motion alarm in West Neck was activated on Nov. 7. An officer searched after finding a door ajar. No signs of criminality were found and the owner was notified.

A smoke alarm activation in Ram Island was deemed no emergency after a canvass by SIFD and the responding police officer; the owner was notified.

A basement smoke alarm in the Heights was activated on Nov. 11. Police and SIFD responded. Second Assistant Chief P.J. Lechmanski determined a false alarm.

A residential motion alarm was activated in the Center on Nov. 12; it was determined to be caused by excessive winds.

AIDED CASES

Shelter Island Town Emergency Medical Services and Stony Brook Paramedic responded to aided cases on Nov. 6 (2), 7(2), 9 (2), 10 and 12 (2).

Six persons were transported to Eastern Long Island Hospital for further treatment. Two persons refused medical treatment.