Amara Goodale represents Island at State championships
Shelter Island’s Amara Goodale triumphed through a difficult County championship race two weeks ago to qualify for the New York State Cross Country Championships, where she raced this past Saturday, Nov. 14.
Goodale finished with a time of 22:51, placing 89th out of 112 Class D girls runners. She improved her time by a minute and 37 seconds after running a 24:28 last November, when she qualified for the race as an 8th-grader.
The championship course, located in Queensbury, N.Y., starts in an open field before winding through a thick patch of woods for much of the 3.1-mile race, eventually looping back toward the starting line. Goodale’s training, as well as her experience from last year’s race, likely contributed to her faster time this season.

“I’d go as close to a turn as I could, and slowly cut across the trail if it was on the other side, so you can kind of hug that turn, and that shaved some time off, and it didn’t use as much energy,” she said following the weekend race.
But she added that she hopes to run a lot faster in her remaining years of eligibility, shaving another minute off her time by next November. Breaking the 20-minute mark is the ultimate goal for her high school career.
Head Coach Erin Baskin told the Reporter that a sub-20-minute run could likely place Goodale in the top 10 or higher, assuming the competition runs similar times in the coming years.
“I think that’s a really realistic and reasonable goal for her to keep pushing for,” Coach Baskin said. “And based on her numbers from the last two years, it’s something she’s been chipping away at, and we still have three seasons to do it.”
Goodale decided to take the winter track season off but will return to Shelter Island School’s running teams this spring, followed by cross country next fall. This winter, following a short recovery period from a partial tear near her calf ahead of the postseason, she plans to run a number of races independently and train alongside her family.
Shelter Island High School has built a serious reputation for running, not just in recent years, but through generations of runners, including the team qualifying a runner for the State championships five consecutive years as of this year.
The Green family, for instance, is one of those staples. Toby Green, who ran in high school, and set multiple records, and took over as coach a number of years ago before passing the reins to Coach Baskin. Mr. Green’s sons, Joshua and Jason, also had successful high school careers and continue to train and run today and are perennial top finishers in the Island’s 10K and 5K races.
The Green brothers are Amara Goodale’s cousins, and while she says they weren’t that close before she started running, the sport has brought them together. Goodale spent much of her summer running with them and plans to do the same this winter.
Discussing the Greens, Goodale explained, “They definitely motivated me to become better than what I wanted to become. I definitely give them a lot of credit for where I am now, and for where I’m going to be in the future.”
Coach Baskin added, “She comes from a legacy that is so incredible and well known on the Island. Our former coach Toby Green is a legend. His sons are training hopefully for the Olympics, so to be a part of that journey, I think is really special.”
Coach Baskin said immediate family members weren’t the only ones offering support ahead of the race. “We actually got a card from somebody from the Island to congratulate Amara. Just, we saw you in the paper, and we’re so proud that you’re running for Shelter Island,” she explained. She added that a number of Shelter Island runners from the past 15 years had reached out in some way ahead of the race.

