05.13.2026 Featured Story Prom: A night for Shelter Island School students to remember This year’s prom took place on May 9 at the Shelter Island House. The theme was “A Night in Vegas.” A big credit for the event is due to...
04.08.2026 Featured Story Patrica Goff awarded Beacon of Excellence by School District Patricia Goff is “second to none,” Shelter Island School District Personnel Director Todd Gulluscio said about the March Beacon of Excellence Award. He presented the award at the March...
02.19.2026 Featured Story Country Club drops plan to buy Shelter Island House for staff housing Gardiner’s Bay Country Club (GBCC) has decided not to pursue the purchase of the Shelter Island House, a hotel on Stearns Point Road that was to be used for...
10.10.2025 Featured Story GBCC proposes purchasing of Shelter Island House for staff Gardiner’s Bay Country Club is on target to solve its staff housing problem with a $5.5 million purchase of Shelter Island House on Stearns Point Road. Members of the...
04.28.2025 Featured Story Prose & Comments: History — personal and Island-wide BY CHRIS CAREY My family first came to Shelter Island from Brooklyn in 1952. Our father, Hugh, drove my mother, Helen, and five children past Lake Panamoka, heading east...
Shelter Island Reporter
