Reporter’s Photo Quiz: What Is That? Nov. 21, 2026
If you know, let us know. Send your responses to [email protected] or phone 631-275-1859.
Roger McKeon was first in his class again, identifying last week’s photo (see below). Roger wrote: “It’s the upper gallery on the outside of the Shelter Island Heights hardware store (aka Ace).”

Pat Hanson wasn’t far behind with the correct answer, writing, “They have everything one could need.”
And Linda Cass proved she knows her Island, and the hardware store.
The photo brought back happy memories to Regina Hartley: “It’s the second story of the hardware store. I’ve been walking by that for over 60 years. My parents’ first rental house, before we bought in 1960, was down on Chase Creek, the Cummings house.”
Jennifer Allen weighed in: “The store that Meredith Page and David Gurney own and operate. I’ve known them since they were little kids so I hope I got this one right!” No worries, Jennifer.
On Facebook Trish Anzalone got it right, as did Cynthia Michalak, and Jennifer Venth, who added, “Ace is the place.” And Mary Fran Gleason concurred, writing, simply, “Exactly.”
Michael Williams called with a memory of the place. When he was working as a plumber for Bill Payne, they were responsible for installing all plumbing in the “new” Heights Post Office across the street in 1964. “The old post office is where the hardware store is now,” Michael said.

