Featured Story

Shelter Island Reporter Editorial: Up To Us

The mid-term Blue Wave election — Tsunami, Earthquake, fill in your own superlative — that gave a large majority to Democrats in the House of Representatives and State houses across the country, as well as a comfortable majority in the U.S. Senate, was also felt on Shelter Island, although here it was more tremor than quake.

Republican Rep. Nick Lalota won re-election, and we congratulate him on his victory. But Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul cruised to victory and, closer to home, the Island’s representative in the State Senate, Republican Anthony Palumbo, lost his bid for another term to Christopher Murray, and Democrat Tommy John Schiavoni won a landslide reelection to the Assembly against former Town attorney Stephen Kiely.

The stunning election was a call to repudiate the Trump administration’s policy on immigration — one that favors sadism over security — senseless tariffs and a calamitous war. Voters also were fed up with corruption, with the Trump family and acolytes taking in bribes with both hands. Add to that a Republican Congress abject in its obeisance to the president and you had the makings of an historic election.

It was also a vote against the sociopathic billionaires who have a seat at the president’s table. The new Gilded Age oligarchs are loudly telling their fellow Americans that the future in the form of AI is here, so get on board or get out of the way when it comes to the construction of data centers that will pave over open space, deplete water tables and gorge on electricity supplies. They scoff at regulations by a government they are proud to despise.

All this for the sake of a future that even they don’t fully understand, not just what government handouts to their companies will cost — with us footing the bill — or the cost to the environment, but whether they will be able to control their bright, shiny technology once it fully develops — heaven help us — a mind of its own. 

Now it’s up to the Democrats to use the power they’ve earned, and Republicans to read the writing on the wall the voters have written. Here’s hoping Congressman LaLota will be one of those who will lead rather than follow, and understand the magnitude of the first article of our founding document establishing Congress as a co-equal branch of government, and not merely a receiver of dictates from the executive branch. 

Immigration, tariffs, war and AI are the concerns of the present age that will define Americans. It’s time to debate, reach consensus, and act.