Shelter Island Reporter Real Estate Transfers: May 30, 2025

Listings prepared for Times Review Media Group by Suffolk Vision Inc., dated March 21, 2025.

SHELTER ISLAND (11964)

• Jill Diepold & Jane Babinski Trust to NY03 LLC, 33 Burns Road (700-15-4-105.007) (V) $375,000

SHELTER ISLAND Heights (11965)

• Susan Spencer to 48 Stearns Point Road LLC, 48 Stearns Point Road (700-13-2-27) (R) $1,450,000

EAST MARION (11939)

• 240Strat LLC to Paul & Christina Brennan, 240 Stratmores Road (1000-21-1-10) (R) $905,000

FISHERS ISLAND (06390)

• Andrea & H. Lawrence Ross to Peter & Holly Gordon, 1027 Castle Road (1000-5-1-4) (R) $2,500,000

GREENPORT (11944)

• Estate of Linda Dickson to Alison Omens & Nikolei Kaplanov, 176 Central Avenue (1001-5-1-6) (R) $1,250,000

• Estate of Marie Cardalena to John & Alexandra Hinchen, 514 Main Street (1001-4-3-30) (R) $926,000

JAMESPORT (11947)

• Estate of Eileen Villani & Richard O’Dea to 299 Herricks Lane LLC, 299 Herricks Lane (600-22-2-5.002) (V) $330,000

LAUREL (11948)

• Maureen Papa to Kyle & Krista Sanderson, 75 1st Street (1000-126-10-9.005) (R) $1,250,000

MATTITUCK (11952)

• Edward & Arlene Fox to Ernest & Anne Albert, 2503 Camp Mineola Road Extension (1000-122-9-9.004) (R) $4,650,000

• Steven & Diane Bellavia to Jorgo & Christina Cikolla, 380 Luptons Point Road (1000-115-11-21) (R) $1,200,000

• Derek & Carrie Genoino to North Fork Landholdings LLC, 270 Harvest Lane (1000-120-3-8.015) (R) $835,000

ORIENT (11957)

• Suzanne & William Nystrom & James A. Scaringe to William & Suzanne Nystrom, 1815 King Street (1000-26-2-43.006) (R) $50,000

PECONIC (11958)

• Madeleine Sinclair to Katherine Reid & Melissa Powell, 275 Sound Avenue (1000-67-2-7) (R) $930,000

SOUTHOLD (11971)

• Evan Geoffroy to Peter & Maureen May, 2505 Wells Avenue (1000-70-4-18) (R) $1,575,000

• 3200 Bay LLC to Meaghan Jones, 500 Arshamomaque Avenue (1000-66-2-61) (R) $1,537,500

• Anne & Joseph Nolan Trust to Robert & Deirdre O’Connell, 9030 Soundview Avenue (1000-59-7-27.003) (R) $1,200,000

• 34892 County Road 48 LLC to Five Star Holdings Management 2 LLC, 34892 County Road 48 (1000-69-4-1.001) (C) $650,000

• Cozy Corp 79 to ANEK Holdings LLC, 1235 Youngs Avenue (1000-60-2-4) (C) $550,000

(Key: Tax map numbers = District-Section-Block-Lot; (A) = agriculture; (R) = residential; (V) = vacant property; (C) = commercial; (R&E) = recreation & entertainment; (CS) = community services; (I) = industrial; (PS) = public service; (P) = park land; as determined from assessed values in the current tax rolls.)