Commander Cody’s Archives - Shelter Island Reporter

02.06.2025 Featured Story

Where to shop, where to eat on Shelter Island for the perfect Valentine’s Day

Islanders know that even in the middle of quiet February, our unique shops are well-stocked with gifts that say, “You are special.” Cornucopia — 631-749-0171 — Mary Lou Eichhorn...

10.26.2024 Featured Story

Shelter Island Quick Quiz: Justin Maggio answers the Reporter’s questions

Q: Favorite event, Fireworks, 10K, 5K Run/Walk? A: This might get me in trouble with my hardworking friends on the Shelter Island Fireworks Committee but, if pressed, I would...

09.13.2024 Featured Story

A Shelter Island bike tour: Pedaling and partaking of Island treats

Autumn offers some of the best bike riding weather of the year, when even we once-in-a-blue-moon road warriors dust off the old Trek, refill the tires, and venture out...

11.23.2022 Featured Story

Codger’s Column: Thanks for Thanksgiving

Codger’s frequent lunch buddy, Ye Esteemed Shakespearean (YES), last week rolled his eyes theatrically (the air seemed to crackle) when Codger said, “Ye Know Who is back on the...

10.30.2022 Featured Story

Dining options aplenty on Shelter Island: New faces join longtime places

Historically, fall on the Island has been a time when restaurants closed after a busy summer season, and there were few options for finding a hearty meal to-go or...

Explore Our Site

Properties

Tag: Commander Cody’s