02.23.2026 Featured Story Camp for grieving kids returns to Shelter Island The little boy had a question for his mother: “Why am I the only person who doesn’t have a dad?” And the mother, struck suddenly again by grief, had...
02.16.2026 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter Letters to the Editor: Feb. 16, 2026 DISAPPOINTED To the Editor: You have asked me to comment on President Trump’s social media post depicting former President and First Lady Obama as apes. Here you go… It...
01.17.2026 Featured Story What is that? Jan. 17, 2026 If you know, let us know. Send your responses to [email protected] or phone 631-275-1859. Roger McKeon wasted no time identifying last week’s photo (see below): “It’s the Manhanset Chapel.”...
12.31.2025 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter obituary: John J. Gereghty John J. Gereghty of Norwalk, Conn., and formerly of Shelter Island, passed away on Friday, Dec. 26, 2025. He was 75 years old. The Liturgy of Christian Burial will...
12.24.2025 Featured Story Never to be forgotten: Island faith leaders on their most memorable Christmases Memorable Christmases often involve trips, of going home or picking up loved ones, or interior journeys, where certain truths and values are realized. For Father Charles McCarron, pastor of...
Shelter Island Reporter
