03.10.2026 Featured Story New superintendent at Shelter Island Country Club One of the highest points on the Island, Goat Hill, has been the scene of delighted gatherings in the wake of recent heavy snows, as it’s famed for being...
02.19.2026 Featured Story Country Club drops plan to buy Shelter Island House for staff housing Gardiner’s Bay Country Club (GBCC) has decided not to pursue the purchase of the Shelter Island House, a hotel on Stearns Point Road that was to be used for...
02.11.2026 Featured Story The taxwoman cometh According to Shelter Island’s Receiver of Taxes, Annmarie Seddio, the highest combined tax bill (see chart below) sent from her office goes to Cape Pridwin Owner, LLC. This limited...
01.29.2026 Featured Story Shelter Island Reporter full obituary: Carol Hallman Carol Hallman, 79, of Shelter Island passed away peacefully at the Kanas East End Hospice Center in Westhampton Beach on Jan. 26, 2026. Carol was born on Sept. 21,...
11.24.2025 Featured Story Gardiner’s Bay Country Club site plan approved: Seven conditions set Gardiner’s Bay Country Club (GBCC) officials won the day, with approval by the Town Board of its site plan allowing for a pumping station structure and cistern to be...
Shelter Island Reporter
