Featured Story

Shelter Island Justice Court reports: Nov. 18, 2023

The following cases were adjudicated at Shelter Island Justice Court on Oct. 2 and 16, 2023 as reported by the court.

Except where indicated, the following defendants pleaded guilty to the charges as noted and were also assessed a $93 state surcharge.

Judge Stanley I. Birnbaum was on the bench Oct. 2, 2023.

John R. Andrew, registration violation, fined $75 plus $93. A charge of operating a vehicle with a suspended registration was dismissed.

Marina L. Hahn, pedestrian violation, reduced from speeding 42 mph in a 25-mph zone, $75.

Jose Medrano, aggravated unlicensed operation, covering number plate violation, $400 plus $93.

Andrea L. Mitchell, no visible distress signal on a vessel, $25.

Karilla Altman, parking without permit, $50.

Deemed scofflaws for failure to appear were Richard M. Blair on a vessel violation; Stephen G. Gafford on vessel regulation and reckless operation charges; Jorge Ramirez Perez, no safety glass; Joseph C. Robinson, vessel regulation violation.

A warrant was continued for Christopher D. Carnes on charges of aggravated harassment.

Criminal summonses were issued for Brett Kincaid, failing to appear on a charge involving dogs; and Dawn Pepitone, allowing a dog to run at large.

Eight cases were adjourned to later dates on the court calendar at the request of defendants or their attorneys; six at the request of the court.

Judge Stanley I. Birnbaum was on the bench Oct. 16, 2023.

Brett Kincaid, parking without permit, $75.

Sarah J. Hollifield, driving while intoxicated, covering turn signal and one-way violations, $500 plus $400.

Miguel Salinas Penafiel, undersized sea bass, $75 plus $75.

Grant M. Smith, pedestrian violation, reduced from speeding 40 mph in a 25-mph zone, $75.

Michael J. Tews, pedestrian violation, reduced from leaving the scene of an accident, $100.

Jules Tyson, failure to display number, $50 plus $93.

Five cases were adjourned to later dates on the court calendar, three at the request of defendants or their attorneys and two at the request of the court.

Deemed a scofflaw for failure to appear was Kevin M. McCafferty on a charge of no inspection certificate.

Judge Mary-Faith Westervelt was on the bench Oct. 2 and 16, 2023.

Three cases were adjourned to later dates in the court calendar at the request of the defendants or their lawyers on Oct. 2.

A warrant for Santolo Esposito on criminal mischief and criminal trespassing was continued on Oct. 16.