Vine Street Cafe Archives - Shelter Island Reporter

02.11.2026 Featured Story

A delicious Valentine’s Day: Local spots offer sweets and gourmet treats

Islanders know these classic spots on the Island bring a smile on Valentine’s and throughout the year: Stars Cafe — 631-749-5345 — Always outstanding, Lydia’s baked treats will be...

02.06.2025 Featured Story

Where to shop, where to eat on Shelter Island for the perfect Valentine’s Day

Islanders know that even in the middle of quiet February, our unique shops are well-stocked with gifts that say, “You are special.” Cornucopia — 631-749-0171 — Mary Lou Eichhorn...

11.16.2023 Featured Story

Enjoying Shelter Island Thanksgiving dinner at restaurants or at home

This Thanksgiving, there are many local options, whether it’s to celebrate the holiday at a restaurant, have dinner catered or forage for favorite dishes. The Chequit — 631-749-0018 Order...

12.21.2022 Featured Story

Shelter Island takeout options for holiday meals

Shopping, wrapping, hiding gifts? Writing cards and…cooking?! Look no further than these local shops to provide holiday meals and treats — a present to yourself. Eccentric Bagel 631-749-5363 In...

12.15.2022 Featured Story

Shelter Island holiday hospitality: Music and meals served up for special times

Islanders have had a wealth of outdoor events to mark the December holidays, from the Windmill Lighting at the Sylvester Manor Farm to the Christmas Parade and the evening...

Explore Our Site

Properties

Tag: Vine Street Cafe